The Future of Primary Care in BC: Why Rural Communities Need a New Model

For too many British Columbians, especially those living in rural and remote regions, timely access to consistent, quality primary care remains elusive. The reliance on a “revolving door” of transient providers and a lack of longitudinal mental and physical health services has created a system that is failing those most at risk of ill health.

A discussion paper from BC Policy Solutions, The Future of Primary Health Care in BC: We can and must do better, offers a critical analysis of where our current system is falling short and provides an evidence-based roadmap for transformation. For rural communities, this report is not just academic; it highlights a path toward the sustainable, team-based care that rural British Columbia desperately needs.

The Rural Reality: A System in Need of Change

The report acknowledges a hard truth: current Ministry of Health investments have often been “too limited or ineffective” for rural and remote populations. While the 2018 primary care strategy promised a shift toward team-based “Patient Medical Homes,” the rollout has been fragmented.

In many rural areas, the resulting Primary Care Networks (PCNs) have functioned primarily as funding conduits for individual hires rather than developing the infrastructure needed to create integrated, community-governed health hubs. As the report points out, when primary care is treated as a physician-only business model, it fails to meet the needs of people living with complex chronic health and social challenges, conditions that are prevalent across the socio-economic gradients found in our rural communities.

A New Path Forward: Lessons for Rural Health

The author, Marcy Cohen, argues that BC needs to move toward a Learning Health System (LHS) framework. This is an evidence-based approach where information is transparently shared through regular reporting, practice facilitation, and peer learning. For rural BC, this approach offers three key opportunities:

1. Empowering Not-for-Profit Community Hubs
The report highlights the potential of not-for-profit, team-based primary care organizations to act as community hubs. Unlike private practices, these organizations have the legal mandate to raise, hold, and disburse funds to address local gaps. In a rural context, this is vital; it empowers communities to tailor services to their specific needs, whether that is addressing travel burdens, stabilizing local clinics facing closure, or creating new referral pathways between organizations.

2. Prioritizing Rural-Specific Data
To move beyond “provincial averages” that often mask the challenges faced by smaller, high-needs populations, the report emphasizes the need for disaggregated data. Rural communities need anchored, evidence-based metrics to track their specific realities, such as:

  • Emergency transfer delays.
  • ER closures.
  • Travel burden to reach primary care.
  • Intermittent access to care providers.

By tracking these indicators, the province could better identify which strategies work and where new, targeted investments are required.

3. Optimizing Team-Based Care
The report suggests that BC must evolve its payment models to fully support team-based, integrated care that is not dependent on a physician’s compensation model. In rural areas, where family physician shortages are acute, this is critical. By empowering other team members, such as nurses, nurse practitioners, clinical pharmacists, social workers, and peer counsellors, to work to their full scope of practice, rural communities can expand their workforce capacity, improve care quality, and enhance cost-effectiveness.

The Foundation for Transformation

As the report concludes, there is a notable alignment among practitioners and community leaders on the direction needed. Transforming BC’s primary care investments into a sustainable, equitable, and high-performing system will not be easy, but the foundation for shared purpose is there.

For rural British Columbia, “doing better” means moving away from a volume-based, physician-centric model and toward a community-governed, integrated, and data-driven approach that addresses the whole person, wherever they live in the province.

—

Read the full discussion paper, “The Future of Primary Health Care in BC: We can and must do better,” by Marcy Cohen, here.